Open Brain
arXivPaperNeeds Review

How far does a hash-only sender go? A pre-registered map of sender memory versus bits for short text messages

A pre-registered test finds the hash-only sender costs more bits than an in-domain PPM sender once failed deliveries need fallback text. The study mainly maps a narrow compression tradeoff, not an agent workflow.

arXiv · Nov 6, 2026
Open Source Open MarkdownOpen JSON
Source Summary

On **1,000** Taskmaster-1 utterances, the hash-only sender delivered 857 on the first try and cost **192.8 bits per message** for complete delivery, 18.4 bits more than PPM order 1. Recovering half the failures with a wider receiver search lowered the bit cost by 7.7 bits versus PPM, but took about three minutes of receiver time per failure.

Practical Implication

For builders choosing compact text transmission, account for the full retry path: acknowledgements and raw-text fallback can erase the initial savings. The sender's memory-versus-bits curve also matters if the device has a strict memory budget.

Agent-Ready Context
On **1,000** Taskmaster-1 utterances, the hash-only sender delivered 857 on the first try and cost **192.8 bits per message** for complete delivery, 18.4 bits more than PPM order 1. Recovering half the failures with a wider receiver search lowered the bit cost by 7.7 bits versus PPM, but took about three minutes of receiver time per failure.

For builders choosing compact text transmission, account for the full retry path: acknowledgements and raw-text fallback can erase the initial savings. The sender's memory-versus-bits curve also matters if the device has a strict memory budget.

This is one pre-registered run on English utterances from one dataset. Airtime comparisons vary by link, and the wider receiver search still loses to PPM on four of five priced links.
Connected Context · Feed7 Judgment

This quantifies how retry and receiver-search costs can erase the initial savings of hash-only text transmission, with results varying by link and a single English dataset. It reinforces evaluating total delivery cost under the actual device and channel constraints rather than judging compression by first-pass bits alone.

Context Map
industrydata
Uncertainty
This is one pre-registered run on English utterances from one dataset. Airtime comparisons vary by link, and the wider receiver search still loses to PPM on four of five priced links.